Music: Dakota Boyer/Michelle Hamilton Lyrics: Michelle Hamilton You and I We weren’t always that good to each other You lied I cried we’d fight all the time Oh but now When I thought that things had just gotten better I found out about all the things that you tried to hide You never come in on time And you always out with your guys I didn’t see it no I believed it All your lies Why’d you lie? I know that I should be done with you But I can’t I can’t I can’t stop loving you Oh why why’d you have to play with my mind I just stopped thinking about you You got me thinking about us But we’re through You never come in on time And you always out with your guys I didn’t see it no I believed it All your lies Why’d you lie?